Stories of historical murders on the South Shore

John F. Gallagher

Passion, Poison, and Pretense

The Murder of Hingham’s Postmaster
“Passion, Poison, and Pretense: The Murder of Hingham’s Postmaster” by John F. Gallagher is a historical novel that delves into the true crime story of the 1857 murder of Hosea J. Gardner, the postmaster of Hingham, Massachusetts. The narrative explores the events leading up to Gardner’s death, the subsequent investigation, and the trial that followed. Suspicion quickly fell upon his wife, Abigail Gardner, and the novel provides a detailed account of her arrest and the legal proceedings that ensued. Drawing from extensive research, including trial notes and historical records, Gallagher presents a vivid portrayal of this 19th-century crime and its impact on the local community.

"I was gripped by this account of the 1857 Gardner murder — a detailed, absorbing, and compelling page-turner. John Gallagher has given historical fiction fans another richly satisfying, complicated, and well-researched story. Bravo!~Annie Hartnett, author of Rabbit CakePassion, Poison, and Pretense: The Murder of Hingham’s Postmaster is the type of local history story I have been craving for some time -a concise, engaging, true story of one of the earliest and most well documented murder cases in Massachusetts, right here in our backyard. Filled with wonderful detail, John's book touches not only on this fascinating piece of Hingham history but also how it fits into the broader history of the development of the judicial system in the fledgling United States. I couldn't put it down!"

Michael Achille, Collections Manager, Hingham Historical Society